beads/docs/reference/json-schema.md
Athos Bernardes 3102cbd4d4
fix(show): flag comment_count as omitted when comments are not streamed (#4865)
* fix(show): flag comment_count as omitted when comments are not streamed

bd show --json's count-only default (be-ijck6q, pinned by
TestJSONContract_ShowOmitsOptInPayloadsByDefault) returns comment_count
with no comments key unless --include-comments is passed. A caller that
checks only `.comments` reads absence as "no comments" — wrong whenever
comment_count > 0. A caller that reads comment_count has no signal that
the array was left out on purpose rather than omitted by a client bug.

Add comments_omitted (bool, omitempty) to IssueDetails, set true only
when CommentCount > 0 and Comments was not populated. Leaves the
count-only default and its perf rationale untouched — this does not
revert cfcc95799/e538f2881, it makes the partial representation
self-announcing. Symmetric dependent_count/dependents case is a known,
separate gap left for a follow-up (not reported by ga-clgh, out of
scope here).

Did not bump JSONSchemaVersion / regen the golden corpus: this adds an
optional field via omitempty (no existing consumer's parse breaks,
no existing corpus fixture has comment_count > 0 for `show`), and
corpus-regen needs a live Dolt+Docker this sandbox doesn't have to
verify. Deferring that call to whoever can run `make corpus-regen` and
review the diff.

Fixes ga-clgh.

* fix(show): set comments_omitted on the proxied path too

The direct path flags comment_count as omitted when comments are not
streamed (ga-clgh); the proxied path silently left the flag unset. Mirror
the else-branch in proxiedBuildDetails, add proxied-path coverage for
present/included/zero cases, and document comments_omitted in the JSON
schema reference. No schema version bump: additive optional field already
emitted by the direct path.

Addresses the 2026-07-23 review on gastownhall/beads#4865.

Agent-Signature: claude-sonnet-5-medium on behalf of maphew

---------

Co-authored-by: matt wilkie <maphew@gmail.com>
2026-07-25 16:16:41 -07:00

6.3 KiB

title description
JSON Output Schema Contract The stable JSON output contract for bd --json commands, covering the schema_version envelope, per-command fields, and consumer guidelines.

Last reviewed: 2026-05-08

Freshness source: cmd/bd/output.go, cmd/bd/errors.go, and cmd/bd/protocol/json_contract_test.go.

All bd commands that support --json output can wrap their response in a uniform envelope by setting BD_JSON_ENVELOPE=1. This will become the default format in v2.0.

Migration Guide

Opt in to the envelope format

export BD_JSON_ENVELOPE=1

Envelope format (BD_JSON_ENVELOPE=1, default in v2.0)

Every --json command wraps output as:

{"schema_version": 1, "data": <original-payload>}

The original payload is untouched inside .data — no type corruption, no field injection. Works identically for objects, arrays, and maps.

Updating consumers

# Before (legacy):
bd list --json | jq '.[0].id'
bd show beads-abc --json | jq '.title'

# After (envelope):
bd list --json | jq '.data[0].id'
bd show beads-abc --json | jq '.data.title'

# Version check:
bd show beads-abc --json | jq '.schema_version'

Timeline

  • Current release: Legacy format is default. Set BD_JSON_ENVELOPE=1 to opt in. A deprecation notice is printed to stderr when --json is used without the env var.
  • v2.0: Envelope becomes the default. BD_JSON_ENVELOPE=0 available as temporary escape hatch for one release cycle.

Schema Version

Current version: 1

The schema_version field is an integer that increments when:

  • Fields are added, renamed, or removed
  • Output structure changes (e.g., nesting depth)
  • Field types change (e.g., string to integer)

Additive changes (new optional fields) do NOT bump the version.

Output Formats

Envelope mode (BD_JSON_ENVELOPE=1)

All commands emit a uniform envelope:

{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "data": {
    "id": "beads-abc",
    "title": "Example issue",
    "status": "open"
  }
}

Arrays are wrapped the same way:

{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "data": [
    {"id": "beads-abc", "title": "First"},
    {"id": "beads-def", "title": "Second"}
  ]
}

Legacy mode (default, until v2.0)

Object commands (show, create, close, update, etc.)

Commands that return a single issue or result emit a JSON object with schema_version as a top-level field alongside the data:

{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "id": "beads-abc",
  "title": "Example issue",
  "status": "open",
  "priority": 1,
  "issue_type": "task",
  "created_at": "2026-04-20T12:00:00Z"
}

List commands (list, ready, search, stale, etc.)

Commands that return multiple items emit a raw JSON array:

[
  {"id": "beads-abc", "title": "First", ...},
  {"id": "beads-def", "title": "Second", ...}
]

Error output (stderr)

Errors with --json active emit JSON to stderr:

{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "error": "issue not found: beads-xyz",
  "code": "not_found"
}

Field Contracts by Command

bd list --json

Required fields per item:

  • id (string): Issue ID (e.g., "beads-abc")
  • title (string): Issue title
  • status (string): open, in_progress, closed, deferred
  • priority (number): 0-4
  • issue_type (string): bug, feature, task, epic, chore
  • created_at (string): RFC3339 timestamp

Optional fields:

  • description, owner, updated_at, closed_at
  • labels (string[]): Attached labels
  • dependencies (object[]): Dependency records
  • dependency_count, dependent_count, comment_count (number)
  • parent (string|null): Parent issue ID

bd ready --json

Same schema as bd list --json. Items are filtered to unblocked issues only. Each item includes dependency_count, dependent_count, comment_count, and optional parent fields.

bd blocked --json

Returns issues that are blocked by unresolved dependencies. Each item includes all standard issue fields plus:

  • blocked_by_count (number): Number of blocking dependencies
  • blocked_by (string[]): IDs of blocking issues

bd show --json

Returns a single object (not wrapped in items). Same required fields as list items, plus:

  • description (string)
  • acceptance_criteria (string)
  • dependencies (object[]): Full dependency records
  • comments (object[]): Comment thread — present only with --include-comments; the default response returns comment_count only (count-only, be-ijck6q)
  • comments_omitted (boolean, optional): true only when comment_count is nonzero and comments was left out of the response (no --include-comments). Absent when comments were included or when there are none to omit (ga-clgh)

import --json

Returns a summary object when --json is active:

  • source (string): File path or "stdin"
  • created (number): Issues created
  • updated (number): Existing issues updated
  • skipped (number): Issues skipped (stale rows + dedup)
  • dedup_skipped (number): Issues skipped by --dedup title match
  • memories (number): Memory records imported
  • ids (string[]): IDs of created issues
  • updated_issues (object[]): Per-issue summary of what an update changed
  • tie_kept_local_ids (string[]): Equal-updated_at rows where local state won
  • stale_skipped_ids (string[]): Rows older than the local issue, skipped
  • skipped_dependencies (string[]): Dependency edges whose target id was absent
  • dry_run (boolean): Whether --dry-run was active

bd export --json

Outputs JSONL (one JSON object per line), not wrapped in an envelope. Each line is a self-contained issue or memory record, discriminated by _type ("issue" / "memory"). Export lines do not carry schema_version — that field belongs to the --json command envelope, not to the interchange stream. The interchange's own version marker is the optional _schema header record ({"_schema":"beads-jsonl/1"}), which readers skip.

Consumer Guidelines

  1. Check schema_version on object output. If the version is higher than expected, log a warning but attempt to parse anyway (additive changes are backward-compatible).

  2. For list commands, parse the output as a JSON array directly.

  3. Ignore unknown fields. New fields may be added without bumping the schema version.

  4. Use --json flag, not --format json. The --json flag is the stable contract; --format is for human-readable variants.